Supreme Court rules on petition in Brooklyn Bridge mass arrest case

Supreme Court rules on petition in Brooklyn Bridge mass arrest case

Yesterday, the Supreme Court turned its back on the First Amendment and denied the petition for certiorari in Garcia v. Bloomberg, the constitutional rights case challenging the mass false arrest of 700 peaceful people on the Brooklyn Bridge in 2011 - the largest mass arrest in New York's history and a turning point in the Occupy movement.

Statement from PCJF client Karina Garcia


"I was a public school teacher when I was arrested with 700 others on the Brooklyn Bridge in October 2011. Other teachers were there. So too were nurses, city workers, students, tourists, restaurant workers, reporters and people from all walks of life - and we were all trapped and arrested. Some were moms and dads who were going to be picking up children later that day. We were marching together because we wanted to change the world.

"The police escorted and permitted this peaceful march to proceed and then without warning or notice trapped and mass arrested all of us, even though we had disobeyed no order and followed behind a line of police commanders who led and escorted the march onto the Bridge. In addition to being arrested that day, I had to go to court ten times over two years to defend myself from false charges.

"I was proud to have been a plaintiff in the lawsuit filed by the Partnership for Civil Justice Fund to hold the police and government accountable for trampling on our rights that day. We’ve stood up for our rights for the past five years with the PCJF by our side working pro bono against the unlimited resources of government lawyers. Of course we are disappointed in this outcome, but the litigation was a way of us declaring that we would not be intimidated into silence; we will defend our rights.

"This mass violation of our civil rights made a mockery of the First Amendment, and the courts have failed to correct this injustice. But, as generations of activists have declared before us: The struggle continues."

—Karina Garcia

In refusing to consider the arrestees' appeal, the Court let stand a Second Circuit ruling that poses a clear and present danger to democracy, free speech and a free press. That ruling threatens all those who would join a peaceful police-escorted demonstration, or report on it, that even if they comply with all police directives they can nonetheless be arrested with no warning and be subject to years of prosecution and possibly years of imprisonment.

The obvious constitutional infirmity of this position, which has been rejected by every other circuit that has considered it, makes it likely that this matter will come up through the courts again. When it does the Partnership for Civil Justice Fund is prepared to again defend and stand with those who are arrested merely for exercising their First Amendment rights, as we have in other landmark cases that have successfully altered police response to protest. While this case has ended, this fundamental issue remains alive as the American people engage in protest and dissent in record numbers.

This case has been hard-fought for more than five and a half years and it has been an honor to represent the plaintiffs in this case, who have been steadfast in their determination to win justice.

The Partnership for Civil Justice Fund has been on the front lines of the defense of people’s rights to demonstrate without fear of unjust arrest and the right to access public space for dissent, and we will continue to prioritize this essential fight for freedom. To do that we need your support. Please make a donation today to support the continued work of the PCJF, and help preserve our vital right to demonstrate, a right which became all the more necessary, and all the more in peril, on Jan. 20 with the installation of Donald Trump as President. Join us in fighting back.

Thank you for standing together with us. We can meet every challenge head-on knowing you and PCJF supporters nationwide are by our side.

Defend Freedom,


Mara Verheyden-Hilliard
PCJF Executive Director